The Feathr Blog

What's the Vibe? How Theaters and Orchestras Are Winning Over New Audiences

Written by Isa Hasty | Nov 20, 2026

For many theaters, symphony orchestras, and museums, roughly three out of four patrons are 65 or older. If you market one of these organizations, that number probably comes as no surprise. Those loyal audiences keep the lights on today. The question is who fills the seats ten years from now.

We talked with Jesse GrothOlson, Director of Marketing at A.D. Players Theater, and Natalie Cheshier, founder of Production Marketing, about what's actually working right now. Their answers came back to one idea again and again: stop selling a seat and start selling a feeling.

Lead with the "aboutness"

Jesse borrows a term from a former university colleague: aboutness. It's the feeling at the heart of a show, and he wants every ad to carry it. "I want the marketing to work in the same way that the play is going to work," he says.

This season, A.D. Players is staging The Best Christmas Pageant Ever, a story about rowdy kids who ruin a church pageant and somehow rescue it. So Jesse is running an ad set where every image is sideways, featuring a cast member screaming into a megaphone at the theater's executive artistic director. It's chaotic on purpose. The ad sets the expectation, and the show delivers on it. When the experience matches the expectation, patrons leave happy.

Aboutness stays constant, but the value proposition shifts by audience and channel. Jesse's rough breakdown:

  • Patrons 65+ already love theater. They need a reminder, plus a reason to go now, like a discount or savings offer.
  • Gen X and older millennials may not buy tickets for themselves, but they will for their kids. Family programming and education carry the pitch.
  • Younger audiences respond to an experience, not a product. The pitch is "like going to the movies, but not."

The channel matters too. A direct mail piece and an Instagram ad should feel like the same brand, but they shouldn't look the same. "The internet is a wild and vast place," Jesse says, so ask what will actually play in that space.

Research backs up this segment-by-segment thinking. The Wallace Foundation's study of 25 performing arts groups found that millennials are not a monolith, and that "young people" is too broad a target to market to well.

Sell an evening, not a seat

Natalie frames the core challenge plainly. Asking someone new to attend means asking them to spend money, leave the house, maybe dress up, and sit in a big room for a few hours. Marketing has to convince them that the whole night is worth it.

One of her symphony clients near her Kentucky home base shows what that looks like. For Halloween, the orchestra performs a live score to a classic horror film. Year one was Nosferatu, and it was a test. Year two was the 1931 Frankenstein, and the team set out to make it an event people couldn't miss.

Every detail leaned into the theme:

  • Costumes welcome. The concert fell on October 30, the start of Halloween weekend, so guests didn't have to choose between the symphony and their costume plans.
  • A digital photo booth at the entrance texted guests a photo strip, and gave the orchestra a library of images for next year's promotion.
  • A signature green appletini at the bar, a nod to the monster.
  • Green ceiling lights for the entire film, plus a Halloween playlist as guests arrived.
  • Family-friendly positioning. Terrifying in 1931, manageable for kids today, which opened the door to parents and young adults alike.

The result: attendance nearly doubled, from 243 guests to 429, in a venue of about 550 seats. The orchestra even released some obstructed-view seats to meet demand.

"We pitched it as an evening, an experience," Natalie says. From the lights to the drinks to the costumes, everything felt like Halloween from start to finish.

Give marketing a seat at the programming table

The Frankenstein night worked because marketing helped shape the event itself, not just promote it. Jesse puts it bluntly: "Marketing must have a voice in the programming." Not every arts marketer has that liberty, but it's worth fighting for if you want to be commercially successful.

That voice also changes timelines. A.D. Players picks each season about a year out and announces it in March. Production teams traditionally didn't start on costumes or design until the following August. But modern campaigns need visual assets early.

Take Still Dance the Stars, a future production in which stuffed animals come to life, led by a giant purple hippopotamus. The show opens in February 2028. Jesse needs that hippo costume within 90 days so it can anchor the poster when the season is announced.

Shifting production earlier caused friction at first. But the payoff has been real. This year's Christmas set was nearly finished weeks before opening night, and the set dresser volunteered to build a matching photo-booth set in the lobby. Those themed lobby sets, which Jesse now builds for every show, have become a signature part of the patron experience.

Having campaigns planned in one place helps. When a drip campaign, lookalike audience, or geofence has a fixed launch date, everyone can see why the assets are due when they are.

Natalie adds that sometimes the calendar belongs to someone else. One client planned a jazz-themed concert while a local jazz festival was happening months earlier. The team built ads ahead of schedule so they could geofence the festival, then retarget that audience as the concert approached.

Meet people where they already are

Most potential patrons aren't searching for your symphony or theater by name. So both Natalie and Jesse go find them instead.

Geofence by theme, not just by competitor. Jesse doesn't geofence other venues to poach audiences. He does it to put the right message in front of the right people. At Christmas, that means other holiday performances, including the many local Nutcrackers. For an upcoming show about the sinking of the USS Indianapolis in World War II, it means museums and naval sites. The content of the show tells you where its audience already gathers. Playhouse on the Square in Memphis used the same mix of geofencing and affinity targeting to find 200 new subscribers.

Build partnerships that run both ways. A.D. Players offers acting, playwriting, and public speaking training to local veterans organizations. When a military-themed show comes along, those partners already have a reason to care. This season's presenting sponsor, a wealth management firm, is hosting a free financial workshop at the theater, open to anyone. It isn't theater, but it builds community, and younger audiences tend to put their money where their values are.

Turn every visitor into an audience. Building rentals bring business conferences through A.D. Players' doors, and the rental agreement lets the theater post a QR code. Each scan feeds a Feathr campaign, so those guests can later see ads for shows or business training that match their interests. "Anything I can do to get someone to scan a QR code," Jesse says. Even people who came for something else learn that the theater is easy to reach, has free parking, and feels safe at night.

Lower the barrier to zero

Jesse's north star isn't ticket revenue. It's butts in seats. "Until I'm selling out 70% of my houses, I'm going to give away tickets as much as I can," he says.

His reasoning: people his age and younger grew up with nearly unlimited free entertainment. In that world, the way in is a free sample. "How can they know the value unless we show it to them? And how can we show it to them unless we give it away for free?" A.D. Players' touring company performs at schools and libraries, and every playbill a child takes home includes a buy-one-get-three-free coupon.

Natalie's symphony client uses pay-what-you-wish pricing for an entire concert series held outside the concert hall, in bourbon bars and hotel lounges. Musicians sit in the middle of the room, and guests gather around with food and drinks. Admission can be $0, and no one asks. Both Halloween film concerts used the same model.

The results surprised the team:

  • People pay more than you'd expect when they choose the price.
  • Many first-timers came back. A large share of Nosferatu guests returned for Frankenstein.
  • Returning guests paid more on average the second year, once the orchestra had proven the evening was worth it.

A full house has its own value too. It reassures new guests that they made a good choice, energizes performers, and gives everyone the same experience. As Natalie points out, no one in the room knows who paid what.

Make room for families, and for everyone

For many younger adults, the way into the arts runs through their kids. A.D. Players plans for that. Summer and the holidays, when families and grandparents look for outings, always get the most family-friendly titles. The Best Christmas Pageant Ever has about 15 kids in the cast, so young audiences see themselves on stage.

The theater normally has a no-one-under-five policy, which can be a real hurdle. Parents need an expensive ticket, a babysitter, and a fast drive home. So where a show allows it, A.D. Players adds all-ages performances, with $15 tickets for lap infants instead of the $80 top-tier price. The house is a little noisier, but Jesse says those performances have been wildly successful, and the cast hasn't complained.

Its Arts for All program offers relaxed performances for neurodivergent audiences. House lights stay up, volume and lighting levels come down, and guests can step out and come back freely.

The longer-term dream is onsite childcare. Many parents already know the model from church nurseries: drop the kids off nearby, and get a text if something comes up. "That's going to be a really great way to meet people where they are," Jesse says, "not just by geofencing, but also in age and stage."

Museums are building the same family pipeline. See how WonderTrek Children's Museum is building engaged supporters before it even opens its doors.

Keep it human

Live art is made by people, and younger audiences increasingly care about that. A.D. Players is preparing a message around simply supporting humans: everything on stage, including the music, was made by a person. Jesse's aim is to say it without being negative about anything else. Live performance is different from watching on your phone, and it's more fulfilling.

That raises a fair question for marketers: where does AI fit?

Natalie draws a firm line. Anything public-facing, from graphics to copy, is made and proofread by a person. She uses AI as an assistant. It helps her expand a list of search keywords, learn how other audiences behave online, or adapt a message that worked in a beach town for a client in Oklahoma. "I will never let it replace something that my brain can do," she says.

Jesse calls his approach "iterative instead of generative." He might ask for 20 variations on an idea, then make the artistic call himself. Most arts organizations are badly understaffed, he notes, so a tool that multiplies effort is hard to refuse. But he'll still protect the human side fiercely. "There's a piece of the human soul, and it's in the imperfections, that you simply cannot replace."

Find your vibe, then find your people

Reaching new audiences isn't about abandoning the patrons who love you. It's about packaging the same art in ways that make sense to more people. Lead with the feeling. Turn a performance into an evening. Give marketing a voice early. Go where your future audience already gathers. Make the first visit easy, even free. And then keep showing up.

As Natalie puts it, sometimes you have to throw things at the wall and see what sticks. The organizations seeing growth are the ones willing to experiment, measure, and try again.

Feathr helps arts and culture organizations reach new audiences with geofencing, retargeting, email, and more, all in one place. Book a demo to see how.