Good Marketing Brief

GivingTuesday is weeks out. Here’s what to get right

Rachel Burris Rodriguez on Oct 22, 2026, 8:30:00 AM

Most nonprofit marketing teams are in execution mode right now before the busy giving season. This week is a pause before the push: covering how to use AI to personalize at scale without losing your organization’s voice, what the first 90 days of a new donor relationship should look like, and what one A/B test on a donation page revealed about the trade-off between monthly and one-time giving.

The take-home template

Most AI writing sounds generic because the prompt was generic. Our free AI Brand Template gives your tool your real voice, your impact numbers, your key campaign details, and clear rules so it never invents facts or veers off-brand. Fill it in once (takes about 20 minutes), upload it to Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, or any other tool you’re using, and every session starts already knowing your organization. 

 

Snackable snippets

How nonprofits can use AI for EOY and GivingTuesday 📖

Most nonprofit teams use AI to write emails faster. The more useful applications tend to be elsewhere. Take one strong story and use it as the source material for an entire campaign — an appeal letter, a multi-email series, social posts, and ad headlines can all come from the same starting point. Ask it to role-play as a skeptical donor and tell you where it would stop reading. Paste in mid-campaign results and ask what you could change right now. None of it replaces judgment, but it handles the tedious parts of a hectic season.

 

The AI personalization case nonprofits can borrow from 📖

Generative AI for content personalization at scale (donor stories, newsletters, social posts, ad headlines tailored by segment) has increased engagement by 25-50% in documented cases, while reducing cost per piece of content by 60-80%. Getting there requires clear donor segments and a strong brand brief before any prompting begins.

A thank-you series that builds trust before the next ask 📖

A first-time donor who gives $25 to your appeal and a monthly supporter who renews the same week are at completely different points in their relationship with your organization. First-time donor retention sits near 19%, and how you follow up in the first 90 days is one of the few places that number moves. Send a warm thank-you within 48 hours, follow with a proof-of-impact update a few weeks later, then introduce a light second-gift ask somewhere between the six-week and two-month mark.

 

For your inspiration folder

The American Cornerstone Institute added a monthly giving ask to their main donation page and preselected the monthly option on the form. Recurring donations increased 269.7%, and overall revenue grew 352.7%, but one-time donations dropped by nearly half. Donors with different giving histories may respond better to different versions of the page, like a monthly ask for those who’ve given before and a one-time option for those who haven’t.
Topics: Nonprofits

See all